Best-Ever Vegan Stuffed Peppers Recipe

When I say that this vegan stuffed peppers recipe is the “best ever” I 100% mean it. I have fed this recipe to MANY MANY meat-eaters and although they are typically carnivores, they LOVED it and always request that I make it.

The best part about these vegan stuffed bell peppers is that they are EASY to make. The preparation time is quick and you can clean up and relax while they cook. The filling may sound like a random assortment of ingredients, but trust me, you won’t regret it and the flavors blend together expertly!

Make sure to check out our post on the Best Sides To Eat With Stuffed Peppers for more inspiration!

If you are looking for healthy vegetarian stuffed peppers, feel free to substitute the vegan cheese for regular cheese. This is a popular and easy modification that I make often for these vegan stuffed peppers.

The best part about this modification is that it is easy to feed a picky crowd. If you have someone who wants cheese in their stuffed peppers you can simply add that to their single pepper, while you make the rest of the stuffed peppers vegan for the remaining diners!

Preparing The Bell Peppers

When you are shopping for the peppers that will make up the base of this recipe, I recommend buying organic bell peppers if you can.

If not, find the largest peppers that you can find and try to ensure that they have a flat bottom so that they are able to stand up in the baking dish.

Once you are home, wash and dry the peppers. Then you will get a sharp knife and cut around the top, being careful to not puncture the bottom or sides of the peppers.

Please do this with care, it is difficult to make vegan stuffed peppers if some of the ingredients are falling out the side or bottom. I know, because I have made this mistake before!

Once you cut around the top of the pepper, simply twist and take out the stem and core. You will then use your hands to remove the seeds. If you can’t get all the seeds out, don’t worry. They won’t hurt you and you won’t notice the flavor when eating these easy vegan stuffed peppers.

Finally, you will want to find a baking dish that is exactly the size of your peppers. I use a 12×12 dish for 4 peppers. Size up or down accordingly. You will want your vegan stuffed bell peppers to nearly be touching each other so they can support each other while baking.

Making The Vegan Stuffed Pepper Filling

Making the stuffing for the peppers is quite easy. I do these vegan stuffed peppers with rice, so be sure to have some on hand before you get ready to stuff! If I know that I want stuffed peppers for dinner, I put my rice in a slow cooker earlier in the day so that it is ready when I need it!

If not, you can simply boil one part rice to two parts water. Put the stove on as high as you can and let the pot get to a rolling boil. As soon as all the water is boiled away and the rice is cooked, you are done. I can cook rice in this method in under 10 minutes. If you forget to cook your rice in advance, do not worry, this is a quick fix!

The next large “filler” for these healthy stuffed peppers is beans. You can choose ANY kind of beans you want! I use whichever beans are on hand, but usually black beans or kidney beans. I have easily used 5 or more types of beans to stuff the peppers throughout all my years of making them!

Since these are EASY vegan stuffed peppers, I simply used canned beans. If you want, you can soak your own beans, but I don’t do that often. One can of beans is generally enough, but you can add more depending on the number of people you need to feed.

Finally, you will add the remaining ingredients and mix it all together. It is VERY IMPORTANT to add salt. Not just a little bit, a lot of salt. This adds the flavor and helps accent the taste of the veggies that make up the base of these vegan stuffed bell peppers.

How To Stuff The Bell Peppers

Once your mixture is made, you will begin stuffing the peppers using a spoon. Stand the peppers up in your baking dish and ensure that they are sturdy. Some of the peppers may be wobbly so try and wedge them against the baking dish and another pepper.

If you are adding regular cheese to make these healthy vegetarian stuffed peppers as opposed to just vegan cheese, now is the time to do it. If you are only using one type of cheese for the whole recipe, you can mix the cheese in during the step above.

If you are customizing the peppers based on cheese, you will simply sprinkle some cheese in the base of the individual pepper, then spoon in the filling, then add a little more cheese, then spoon in the filling and so on. Make sure to use your spoon to smoosh down the filling so it is very compact!

IMPORTANT: Finishing The Vegan Stuffed Peppers

This is a VERY IMPORTANT STEP!! Once you have finished stuffing the peppers, you will NOT add cheese to the top. Instead, you will pour some jarred or fresh tomato sauce over the top of all the peppers and down into the dish.

I always use homemade tomato sauce and it is pretty easy, but I have used it from a jar too! I even have a Vegan Tomato Sauce Recipe that is super simple to make up!

You don’t need a lot of sauce in the bottom of the pan, just a little to keep it wet. I will often mix my tomato sauce with a little water to thin it out.

Then I will pour the mixture over the vegan stuffed peppers. As long as the top of the pepper is coated, you should be fine.

After you pour the tomato sauce on your peppers, only then should you add the cheese. It is essential that you do NOT add the cheese before you add the final layer of sauce. You want the cheese to crisp up while baking and it can’t do that if there is a layer of sauce over the top!

Do NOT skip this step if you want a wonderful baked layer of cheese on top of your vegan stuffed peppers!

Eating Your Easy Vegan Stuffed Peppers

I recommend letting this vegan stuffed pepper recipe cool for a few minutes after baking to let the cheese crips up a bit. To eat, I recommend taking the pepper and putting it on your plate and then cutting it in half, starting from the cheese and going to the bottom of the pepper.

Once you but the pepper in half lengthwise, you will take the first half and cut it up into small bite-sized pieces. While you are eating one half, the second half stays warm as it is still in-tact.

I do recommend having a sharp knife to make cutting and eating these delightful vegan stuffed peppers easier and more enjoyable!